Skip to main content
Physics Guru is an online education and competitive examinations preparation portal founded by Manish Verma, an IIT Madras alumnus, providing learning resources for competitive examinations.

The emphasis is on conceptual understanding, analytical thinking and problem solving rather than simply memorising formulas and standard methods.

The objective is to help students understand what they are learning and develop the ability to solve problems they have not seen before.

Does Red Light Become Green in Water?

A person with normal eyesight can see visible light with wavelengths approximately in the range of $400 nm$ to $700 nm$ in air. A diver underwater, where the refractive index of water is $μ=\frac {4}{3}$, is shown a red warning light of wavelength $680 nm$ (in air) to alert him to a nearby danger. Will the diver be able to see the warning light as red? Justify your answer. [Note: A wavelength of $680 nm$ corresponds to red light in air, whereas $510 nm$ corresponds approximately to green light in air.]

Answer

The frequency $\nu = \frac {v}{\lambda}$

In water, the speed becomes $\frac {v}{\mu}$ and the wavelength becomes $\frac {\lambda}{\mu}$. So, the frequency does not change.

The colour depends on the frequency and therefore, red appears as red.

Although the wavelength in water is $λ_{water}=\frac {680}{4/3}=510 nm$,
this does not mean that the light becomes green. The value $510 nm$ corresponds to green light when the wavelength is specified in air, not when it is the wavelength of the same light in water. The calculated wavelength of $510 nm$ is a distractor if it is used to infer a change in colour.