Skip to main content
Physics Guru is an online education and competitive examinations preparation portal founded by Manish Verma, an IIT Madras alumnus, providing learning resources for competitive examinations.

The emphasis is on conceptual understanding, analytical thinking and problem solving rather than simply memorising formulas and standard methods.

The objective is to help students understand what they are learning and develop the ability to solve problems they have not seen before.

Is Free Fall Always Faster?

In a thought experiment, a particle is located at point A and is to reach point B. Initially, the particle is at rest. In one case, particle moves on a frictionless inclined plane AB under gravity. In the other case, particle moves as if it were falling freely from A to O attaining speed v at O and then heads towards B with this speed v in frictionless horizontal path OB. Prove that if the angle of inclination is sufficiently large, it is faster to go directly from A to B but if the angle is below certain threshold value, it is faster to go via the AOB route. Prove that the approximate threshold value of $\theta=37^\circ$. (Neglect air resistance. $sin 37^\circ = \frac {3}{5}$, $cos 37^\circ = \frac {4}{5}$)

Least time to go from A to B

Solution

A-B Direct

Let $AB=L$, $L=0+\frac {1}{2}gsin \theta t^2$

$\therefore t = \sqrt {\frac {2L}{gsin \theta }}$

A-B via O

$v^2=0+2gLsin\theta$

$v=0+gt_{AO}$

$\therefore t_{AO} = \frac {v}{g}$

Also, $Lcos\theta = vt_{OB}$

$t_{AOB}=t'=t_{AO}+t_{OB}$

$\therefore t'=\frac {v}{g}+\frac {Lcos \theta}{v}$

$\therefore t'=\frac {v^2+gLcos \theta}{vg}$

$\therefore t'= (2sin\theta+cos \theta) \sqrt {\frac {L}{2gsin\theta}}$

For A-B direct to be faster, $t<t'$

$\therefore \sqrt {\frac {2L}{gsin \theta }}<(2sin\theta+cos \theta) \sqrt {\frac {L}{2gsin\theta}}$

$\therefore 2<2sin\theta+cos\theta$

At the threshold angle, $2=2sin\theta+cos\theta$ which is satisfied by $sin 37^\circ = \frac {3}{5}$, $cos 37^\circ = \frac {4}{5}$

Therefore, the threshold angle is approximately $37^\circ$.

We are only interested in values of $\theta$ in the interval $(0^\circ, 90^\circ)$ for the function $2sin\theta+cos\theta$. From trigonometry, we know the maximum value of the function is $\sqrt 5$. The second derivative of the function is negative indicating maxima, which means the function increases, attains maxima and then decreases. The starting value is near 1 at near $0^\circ$ then the function reaches value of 2 near $37^\circ$ then it further rises to $\sqrt 5$. When $\theta$ is near $90^\circ $, the function attains a value of around 2.

2 sin(θ) + cos(θ)
Hence,

- If $\theta>37^\circ$, A-B direct route is faster.
- If $\theta<37^\circ$, A-O-B route is faster.
- If $\theta=37^\circ$, both routes take equal time.