In a thought experiment, a particle is located at point A and is to reach point B. Initially, the particle is at rest. In one case, particle moves on a frictionless inclined plane AB under gravity. In the other case, particle moves as if it were falling freely from A to O attaining speed v at O and then heads towards B with this speed v in frictionless horizontal path OB. Prove that if the angle of inclination is sufficiently large, it is faster to go directly from A to B but if the angle is below certain threshold value, it is faster to go via the AOB route. Prove that the approximate threshold value of $\theta=37^\circ$. (Neglect air resistance. $sin 37^\circ = \frac {3}{5}$, $cos 37^\circ = \frac {4}{5}$)
Solution
A-B Direct
Let $AB=L$, $L=0+\frac {1}{2}gsin \theta t^2$
$\therefore t = \sqrt {\frac {2L}{gsin \theta }}$
A-B via O
$v^2=0+2gLsin\theta$
$v=0+gt_{AO}$
$\therefore t_{AO} = \frac {v}{g}$
Also, $Lcos\theta = vt_{OB}$
$t_{AOB}=t'=t_{AO}+t_{OB}$
$\therefore t'=\frac {v}{g}+\frac {Lcos \theta}{v}$
$\therefore t'=\frac {v^2+gLcos \theta}{vg}$
$\therefore t'= (2sin\theta+cos \theta) \sqrt {\frac {L}{2gsin\theta}}$
For A-B direct to be faster, $t<t'$
$\therefore \sqrt {\frac {2L}{gsin \theta }}<(2sin\theta+cos \theta) \sqrt {\frac {L}{2gsin\theta}}$
$\therefore 2<2sin\theta+cos\theta$
At the threshold angle, $2=2sin\theta+cos\theta$ which is satisfied by $sin 37^\circ = \frac {3}{5}$, $cos 37^\circ = \frac {4}{5}$
Therefore, the threshold angle is approximately $37^\circ$.
We are only interested in values of $\theta$ in the interval $(0^\circ, 90^\circ)$ for the function $2sin\theta+cos\theta$. From trigonometry, we know the maximum value of the function is $\sqrt 5$. The second derivative of the function is negative indicating maxima, which means the function increases, attains maxima and then decreases. The starting value is near 1 at near $0^\circ$ then the function reaches value of 2 near $37^\circ$ then it further rises to $\sqrt 5$. When $\theta$ is near $90^\circ $, the function attains a value of around 2.
Hence,
- If $\theta>37^\circ$, A-B direct route is faster.
- If $\theta<37^\circ$, A-O-B route is faster.
- If $\theta=37^\circ$, both routes take equal time.

%20+%20cos(%CE%B8).png)